1886-1904     Rev. C.J. Wilcox

1905-1916     Rev. William H. Fulford  (Founder)

1917-1918     Rev. J.F. Counsel

1919-1920     Rev. Fred Thompson

1921-1922     Rev. J.A. Cornegay

1923-1924     Rev. Langston Livingston Davis

1924-1946     Rev. Saul Davis

1955-1955     Rev. James H. Shivar

1956-1964     Rev. Joseph Highsmith

1964-1967     Rev. Meril McCall

1967-1989     Rev. Douglas Nesbitt

1990-2010     Bishop Linwood Nesbitt

1886-1904     Union Holiness Church                    

1905-1916      Holy Church of the New Covenant

1917-1958      Covenant Holiness Church

1958-2010      New Covenant Holiness Church

*Other Undated Names*

                             Church on the Hill

                             Negro Holy Church

                             Colored Holy Church